|Renoise is built around a software that is being sold.
And there is buzzchurch and modplug as well
And CTG is affiliated with Yannick and his tracker.
I'm not sure what that has to do with a site like TiS which is neutral to the means used to create the art. Obviously the renoise forum would have a problem if several hundred people like me started posting music made in Sonar....
As for success - crap - I'll be happy just to see it come into existence.
When that happens I'll take it from there.... however be it old scene or not - I believe there is value in giving and not everyone can afford their own host to post music to places like CTG.