 |
Forum ~ General ~ How to reduce number of non reviewed songs? |
 |
 |
|  How to reduce number of non reviewed songs? [GENERAL] | |
|
 |
Nifflas
  Member
Topics: 80
Replies: 1599
Registered: 05.Mar.04 |
It takes quite a while to become relatively skilled... I remember that when I was younger, my English was so bad, that I couldn't have a conversation much more advanced than to answer the "asl?" question of doom. It takes quite a while to learn a new language, and it wouldn't really make much sense to review lots of tunes before you do.
 |
|
Xtatic Shiva
 Artist
Topics: 14
Replies: 171
Registered: 16.Mar.06 |
 |
pete ax wrote on 10 Jun. (8:27) :
I think it´s all about english. If you don´t speak english, you cannot write reviews. If one review takes half an hour or more to be written, no one can expect the number of nonreviewed song will go down. People with bad english, will not lose any time with reviewing. My opinion. I think reviews from these people are often reported - reason? too short, too simple (nothing saying). Why it is short and simple.... just fuckin´ bad english.   Dunno how to solve this.
|
Pete's got a point here! Good english is necessary!
I think that more than this, productions skills are necessary as well. I've pointed that out about a month ago.
I had my hesitations about reviewing. I started quite dynamically when i joined the community but when the thought ''Am i a crappy producer indeed???'' crossed my mind i gave up. I worked harder and i got better (i think) as a producer. I had to prove to my self first that i can produce and then get back in reviewing.
How could i review when i couldn't make decent bass and kicks??? How could i ''judge'' another producer's track while I SUCKED??? As i've said,i know what i like but how about the technical parts of a song/track??? I simply can't keep on reviewing sayin' all the time ''I like that'' and ''i didn't like that...''!
Producers have weak and strong skills. One might know a lot about frequencies,another could be better in making nice atmospheres and a third could be a master in making melodies. The combination of all those and many more make a good producer.
But how can you be a good producer if you don't have been educated on music or sound engineering??? Yes,talent is absolutely necessary but still not enough. I think the only possibility is by getting feedback. Not necessarily reviews but feedback. And this is where the ''top rated artists'' should take action. If they don't contribute in this,i don't think that we'll ever reduce that number. If they don't show the will to help how on earth am i supposed to get better??? I've been told that i sometimes make wrong use of fx. But i've never been told how i could use the specific effect in a proper way...
So,IMO will is needed by EVERYBODY!!! Top artists SHOULD give feedback and new not-that-good artists SHOULD be all ears and the opposite. And simply WANT to reduce that number. I know that some tracks are trully not worth the time. But we HAVE to review them. Otherwise we are not as ''active'' as we might think and crappy producers will stay crappy forever.
Maybe i went off topic but these are my thoughts...
Peace!
A '' Mind game'' (298 hits)
in a ''Sanatorium'' (252 hits) |
|
Cooth
Member
Topics: 59
Replies: 3588
Registered: 02.Jan.03 |
Xtatic Shiva wrote on 26 Jun. (10:33) :
How could i review when i couldn't make decent bass and kicks??? How could i ''judge'' another producer's track while I SUCKED??? As i've said,i know what i like but how about the technical parts of a song/track??? I simply can't keep on reviewing sayin' all the time ''I like that'' and ''i didn't like that...''!
|
You don't really need to put focus on technical aspects. As a mere listener, you are still capable of judging the pleasure of listening, comparing to similar productions etc. Listening experience may be even more important than producing. The original idea of a review is evaluation, not teaching. Even if producing tips are good in a community like this, they are not required to make a review valid. |
|
Senjaya
Artist
Topics: 1
Replies: 8
Registered: 10.Mar.06 |
How 'bout the staff from CTG give a review 1st??
and I think give a new page for the non reviewed song.
it should be better if there is a new page esspecialy for those non reviewed song 
Oh & give a obligation to the top 10 ARTIST to review non reviewed song each week.
|
|
Analysis
Artist
Topics: 72
Replies: 6282
Registered: 16.Mar.03 |
|
Senjaya
Artist
Topics: 1
Replies: 8
Registered: 10.Mar.06 |
Analysis wrote on 01 Oct. (11:50) :
Senjaya wrote on 28 Sep. (14:55) :
How 'bout the staff from CTG give a review 1st?? |
HAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA.... uhm... yes, sorry.
|
So how 'bout it?
is it okay that the staff give a review 1st?
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA............. |
|
xTr1m
 Administrator
Topics: 106
Replies: 4441
Registered: 11.Oct.03 |
It's a nice thought, though you forget that we staff members also have a life, and can't stay all day checking out new songs in CTG and review them ALL. Not including the 225 songs that still don't have reviews...
A proud member of CTGMusic Community!
A new release! From Morningstar to Midnight (Reason Remake) (2065 hits) |
|
Analysis
Artist
Topics: 72
Replies: 6282
Registered: 16.Mar.03 |
|
roncli
Administrator
Topics: 55
Replies: 751
Registered: 18.Dec.03 |
Senjaya wrote on 02 Oct. (12:47) :
So how 'bout it?
is it okay that the staff give a review 1st?
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA............. |
Tell ya what. If you manage to give all new songs a first review, I'll give them a second review. Let me know when you've cleaned up all the songs that don't have reviews...
-roncli |
|
tyr
Artist
Topics: 66
Replies: 1054
Registered: 04.Jan.05 |
Kricke wrote on 08 Jan. (18:59) :
DIRECT LINK - Displaying the oldest songs with no reviews.
Go ahead and review the first song you see. 
|
I was gonna, I really was, but it was a metal track
Have you ever wondered? |
|
|
Latest Topics
![[194.153.52.130]](pics/ip.gif){kind=small}
