tyr
  Artist
Topics: 66
Replies: 1054
Registered: 04.Jan.05 |
My own personal project, Im all for reducing the amount of unreviewed songs.
Here is how I'm trying to reduce unreviewed.
Review some unknown's, it's really hard to get a review here, and if the music is bad, someone has to tell them what. At least I belive that is the only way to get better.
Review the guys who have been trying real hard to review and have gotten surprisingly litte back, they deserve some credit in my book. (Yeah, i know about how you get publicity rewards for them but still.)
Been trying some combination of the two, if you see any problem with this plz tell me.
Regards,
Tyr |
|
Analysis
Artist
Topics: 72
Replies: 6282
Registered: 16.Mar.03 |
|
Provos
 Member
Topics: 6
Replies: 516
Registered: 17.Mar.05 |
If everybody returned reviews, the world would perfect.
If half the people here returned reviews, the world would be perfect.
If 5% of the people here returned reviews, the would wouldn't be perfect, but it would be a much better place...
review a song, get a free beer!
new song! provos - Dreamseeker (1119 hits)
slightly newer song! provos - Radience (1004 hits)
even newer song! provos - Chrysalis (911 hits)
teh zombies omg! (2241 hits) |
|
Wiseman
 Staff / Moderator
Topics: 193
Replies: 1559
Registered: 24.Feb.03 |
Provos wrote on 09 Oct. (20:07) :
If everybody returned reviews, the world would perfect.
If half the people here returned reviews, the world would be perfect.
|
I dont like the thought of "returning" a review, even if its not wrong.
But, instead, as a thumbrule, if you get one, do one. For anyone.
And ofcourse, the unreviewd are the best chooise ^^
http://www.wiseman-music.se
http://www.upsweden.com/promo |
|
tyr
Artist
Topics: 66
Replies: 1054
Registered: 04.Jan.05 |
Provos wrote on 09 Oct. (20:07) :
I dont like the thought of "returning" a review, even if its not wrong.
But, instead, as a thumbrule, if you get one, do one. For anyone.
And ofcourse, the unreviewd are the best chooise ^^
|
Hmm, I agree, there could be some bitterness from a bad review or gratitude from good review.
However if you suggested a 3'd party to review, you would still be "returning" the review in a way and still retaining your objectivity. 
Regards,
Tyr |
|
Provos
Member
Topics: 6
Replies: 516
Registered: 17.Mar.05 |
|
tyr
Artist
Topics: 66
Replies: 1054
Registered: 04.Jan.05 |
Nope, me neither until a few minutes ago, it would propably be hard in practice but if prperly executed, it would it improve review quality.
Regards,
Tyr |
|
drumstick
Administrator
Topics: 11
Replies: 352
Registered: 12.Sep.04 |
Man, I was actually starting to like CTG a little more when no one was talking about reviews for a while.  |
|
xa
Artist
Topics: 54
Replies: 2755
Registered: 08.Jun.04 |
drumstick wrote on 09 Oct. (21:51) :
Man, I was actually starting to like CTG a little more when no one was talking about reviews for a while. |
well, the never ending review debate is kinda part of the community imo 
I used to think I had a very refined sense of humour, and that's why people never laughed at my jokes. Now I've realized that I'm just not funny.
- s-f |
|
Louigi Verona
Member
Topics: 384
Replies: 3827
Registered: 22.Aug.03 |
My 2 cents to this review debates are here, in this very article.
An article on reviews at CTG
tyr: read the section about non-reviewed songs - interesting statistics.
http://www.parrots.org/ |
|
|
Latest Topics
![[194.144.4.24]](pics/ip.gif){kind=small}
