 |
Forum ~ Polls ~ how many % reviews on CTG are over-rated in your opinion ? |
 |
 |
|  how many % reviews on CTG are over-rated in your opinion ? [POLLS] | |
|
 |
Nygen Dale
  Staff / Moderator
Topics: 68
Replies: 3617
Registered: 21.Jun.03 |
I'm just trying to get to know how the ppl review. When I get a 7 from Szartd I am more than satisfied... some other users have to give me maybe an 8,5 so that I know that I did a great job... I can live with that system since I'm not heading for rank 1 here. I am glad when my ratings improved compared to earlier songs.
That my € 0,59 cents
www.nd-music.com |
|
Szartd
 Member
Topics: 76
Replies: 1592
Registered: 27.Dec.02 |
Well I saw Storm giving Timbe's song a 9 , and that is what I call overrating , since a 9 is supposed to be near perfect ..... a pro production , everythign must be great .... and what does mr Storm says ? "The soudn can be better" , "That can be better" blah blah ...
So why give it a 9 then ? There are barely songs at CTG that deserve a 9 !
And well , that is wat is frustrating me most ...
And yes ... it is the reviewers own opinion ..... but still .... a 9 ... come on  |
|
Nygen Dale
Staff / Moderator
Topics: 68
Replies: 3617
Registered: 21.Jun.03 |
Let's see how things are going after people have read this thread... 
www.nd-music.com |
|
Randor
Administrator
Topics: 560
Replies: 2948
Registered: 27.Dec.02 |
I've been few days off and noticed while browsing new reviews that there surely is some affect now  That's good direction, if everybody makes his/her line a bit harshen 
 ...............  |
|
Novus
 Artist
Topics: 44
Replies: 438
Registered: 05.Jan.03 |
Heck, I'm just glad someone else is talking about this besides me, and I'm ecstatic that it's someone as high up in an archive admin staff as Szartd is.  
I had a lot to say on this very topic in Scene-Zine #3:
http://www.scenerep.32k.org/scenezine/issue3.php#5
Enjoy.  |
|
FeralCode
Member
Topics: 125
Replies: 1202
Registered: 19.Mar.03 |
Novus wrote on 04 Aug. (6:58) :
Heck, I'm just glad someone else is talking about this besides me, and I'm ecstatic that it's someone as high up in an archive admin staff as Szartd is.
I had a lot to say on this very topic in Scene-Zine #3:
http://www.scenerep.32k.org/scenezine/issue3.php#5
Enjoy. |
Nice article |
|
RAVE-n
Artist
Topics: 22
Replies: 1077
Registered: 28.Dec.02 |
indeed
"... the painted cow..." |
|
Novus
Artist
Topics: 44
Replies: 438
Registered: 05.Jan.03 |
| Why, thank you kindly. |
|
Storm 3003
Artist
Topics: 33
Replies: 2079
User is online 
Registered: 20.Mar.03 |
 |
Szartd wrote on 01 Aug. (18:17) :
Well I saw Storm giving Timbe's song a 9 , and that is what I call overrating , since a 9 is supposed to be near perfect ..... a pro production , everythign must be great .... and what does mr Storm says ? "The soudn can be better" , "That can be better" blah blah ...
So why give it a 9 then ? There are barely songs at CTG that deserve a 9 !
And well , that is wat is frustrating me most ...
And yes ... it is the reviewers own opinion ..... but still .... a 9 ... come on |
This topic is for CTG reviews or for my reviews?
For me the timbe's song is great, i like it alot and i give to it a 9.
Anyway, you say that the 9 or 10 is for a perfect song with a studio quality, but for example, you have rating the song Anoxxia - Echoes - Preview Release, 9,5 but this is a song in IT format, without mastering, is only a piano, without other instruments, the sound quality is pretty evarage, without VST, mastering, compression, etc... So where is here the studio quality and the perfect song?
Sorry mate, but you are wrong here! 
My 15,00 €
PS: For Anoxxia: Mate, don't take me wrong i've use your song only for an exemple. |
|
Szartd
Member
Topics: 76
Replies: 1592
Registered: 27.Dec.02 |
|
Storm wrote on 06 Aug. (17:30) :
Szartd wrote on 01 Aug. (18:17) :
Well I saw Storm giving Timbe's song a 9 , and that is what I call overrating , since a 9 is supposed to be near perfect ..... a pro production , everythign must be great .... and what does mr Storm says ? "The soudn can be better" , "That can be better" blah blah ...
So why give it a 9 then ? There are barely songs at CTG that deserve a 9 !
And well , that is wat is frustrating me most ...
And yes ... it is the reviewers own opinion ..... but still .... a 9 ... come on |
This topic is for CTG reviews or for my reviews?
For me the timbe's song is great, i like it alot and i give to it a 9.
Anyway, you say that the 9 or 10 is for a perfect song with a studio quality, but for example, you have rating the song Anoxxia - Echoes - Preview Release, 9,5 but this is a song in IT format, without mastering, is only a piano, without other instruments, the sound quality is pretty evarage, without VST, mastering, compression, etc... So where is here the studio quality and the perfect song?
Sorry mate, but you are wrong here!
My 15,00 €
PS: For Anoxxia: Mate, don't take me wrong i've use your song only for an exemple. |
It was menth to be an example ! |
|
|
|
|
|
Latest Topics
![[217.255.122.170]](pics/ip.gif){kind=small}
